You’re halfway round your usual loop, the field gate is in sight, and your Collie is scanning the horizon.
Ears forward, body tight, every slight noise noted.
You haven’t seen anything yet. Neither has he.
But he looks like a dog who is absolutely certain that something is about to go wrong.
If you live with a reactive Border Collie, you’ll probably recognise that dog.
And you may well have wondered the very thing Sharon, one of our Collie Culture Club members, asked recently:
“Is it right or helpful to see reactive dogs as more pessimistic so they interpret the world in a more negative way and that leads to the reactivity?
Does our training make them more optimistic or does it just teach them ways to deal with the pessimism?
Can we really change that internal tendency for pessimism and in doing so change the way the dog sees the world?”
It’s a brilliant question.
And the honest answer is more nuanced- and, I think, more hopeful – than the clean-cut version you may have heard.
Because the clean-cut version is everywhere.
👉 Reactive dogs are pessimists.
👉 Build their optimism and the reactivity melts away.
👉 Play the right games and your dog will start to see the world as a friendly place.
It’s a lovely idea, and there is some science in it.
But when you look at what the research actually says, the idea misses some key information.
And for Collie owners in particular, the missing bits are what really matters.
So, are reactive dogs pessimists? Let’s explore.
Can a dog really be a pessimist?
In animal-welfare research, “optimism” and “pessimism” are shorthand for something called judgement bias (you’ll sometimes see it called cognitive bias).
The idea comes from human psychology: how we feel can colour what we expect when we’re not sure what’s coming.
On a bad day, an ambiguous message from your boss saying “can we have a quick chat?” feels ominous. On a good day, it’s probably nothing.
To test this in dogs, researchers teach a dog that a bowl in one spot always has food in it, and a bowl in another spot is always empty.
Once the dog has that sussed, they put the bowl somewhere in between.
Does the dog trot over expecting a treat, or go slowly as if it’s probably going to be disappointing?
A quicker approach to that ambiguous bowl is read as a more “optimistic” judgement. A slower one, more “pessimistic”.
One of the first studies to use this with dogs, from the University of Bristol in 2010, found that dogs showing more separation-related behaviour approached the ambiguous bowls more slowly than dogs who coped better when left alone.
The researchers suggested these dogs may have been in a more negative emotional state overall, and that this was colouring what they expected from uncertainty.
So yes – there is genuine evidence that how a dog feels can influence what they expect when the world is unclear. If your dog is worried, it makes complete sense that an ambiguous shape in the distance might be read as a threat rather that just someone’s wheelie bin.
But here’s the important bit.
In the research, “pessimism” isn’t a label for the dog.
It’s a measure of how quickly a dog walks to a bowl in a carefully controlled test.
It doesn’t mean your dog has a gloomy personality, or is consciously thinking “bad things always happen to me”.
And it certainly isn’t something we can diagnose by watching a dog bark at the end of the lead.
The twist: some reactive dogs look like optimists
This is where it gets really interesting for Collie owners.
A 2018 study looked at personality traits and judgement bias in 31 dogs.
Dogs who scored higher for separation-related behaviour and for fear or aggression towards other dogs were more likely to respond “pessimistically”. So far, so good.
But dogs who scored higher for sociability and excitability approached the ambiguous bowls faster. In other words, they leaned the other way – towards a more “optimistic” bias.
It’s worth reading that again – because I think it changes the whole conversation.
Excitability was linked with optimism, not pessimism.
A dog can be highly aroused, explosive at the end of the lead and almost impossible to call away, while still fully expecting that the ambiguous thing over there might be absolutely brilliant.
Optimistic does not mean calm. It doesn’t mean regulated, polite, or easy to live with.
When we talked about this in the Club, Elaine described how surprise in her dog often means excitement and reactivity.
Corinne talked about a dog who rushes joyfully towards wildlife or people and simply can’t disengage.
Neither of those dogs sounds like a pessimist. Both sound like dogs whose whole system has been recruited, very fast.
Why “just build optimism” isn’t the whole story
So I want to be quite clear here, because I think the popular message – your reactive dog is a pessimist, so the answer is to build optimism – can send some lovely, responsible owners down the wrong path.
Yes – if your Collie is reacting because they’re worried, helping them build more positive expectations may well be genuinely valuable.
But..
Barking and lunging can be the final common pathway for lots of very different things going on inside. From the end of the lead, these can look almost identical:
- “That dog might be dangerous.” A worried dog may bark, lunge, freeze or snap, trying to create distance.
- “That dog might be amazing – I need to get there!” An excited or frustrated dog may pull, lunge, fixate and go up on it’s back legs, trying to close the distance.
- “I’m feeling overwhelmed by multiple triggers and can’t think clearly” An overwhelmed dog will often revert to breed specific superpowers to try and make themselves feel better – in our Collie’s case, try and control things!
If your dog is of the second persuasion, then “more optimism” may not be the missing ingredient at all.
Likewise, a Collie who is responding without thinking to movement might already have plenty of optimism.
What they may need is help with arousal, frustration, impulse control and a different rehearsed response.
And perhaps optimism isn’t always the goal.
A dog who is a little too sure that everything is wonderful can end up in genuinely unsafe situations – charging up to dogs who don’t want company, chasing wildlife, or heading for a road.
Many Collies, if we’re honest, are a mix of several of these at once. And that’s before we think about pain.
When Vodka’s reactivity turned out to be linked to a pain issue – suggested by a behaviourist friend – it was a powerful reminder that what looks like an emotional “outlook” can sometimes have a very physical root.
Pain is always worth ruling out with your vet, and even once it’s treated, the learned response will often need help to be changed too.
So can we change how a dog sees the world?
Now for the hopeful part.
Because if expectations are shaped by experience, then experience can reshape them. And there’s some encouraging evidence that this can happen.
Treatment can shift expectations. A small 2015 study followed dogs with separation-related problems through two months of medication plus a behaviour-modification plan.
Before treatment, these dogs responded more “pessimistically” than the comparison dogs.
By week six, their responses looked similar to the comparison dogs – responding more “optimistically”.
The researchers were specifically asking whether improvement was just dogs holding behaviour in, or a change in how they felt – and the shift in judgement bias suggests the latter.
With only five affected dogs, and medication involved, it’s promising rather than proof. But it does suggest a dog’s expectations aren’t set in stone.
Sniffing and choice may matter. In a 2019 study, dogs who did two weeks of nosework became more “optimistic” than dogs who spent the same time doing heelwork.
The authors pointed to two things nosework offers: the chance to use a natural sensory skill, and more opportunity to make active choices.
This wasn’t a reactivity study, so it’s not evidence that nosework “fixes” reactivity.
But for a breed so often asked to work in tight partnership with us, it’s worth considering the idea that time spent leading with their nose, and making their own decisions, might be more important than we think.
Positive human contact helped fearful dogs. A 2019 study of fearful shelter dogs found that enrichment centred on positive human interaction was associated with less fear-related aggression and more positive expectations.
Training method seems to matter. Two larger studies of pet dogs found that dogs trained with more aversive methods tended to show more “pessimistic” responses than dogs trained with rewards. Perhaps not completely surprising?!
One of them also found more stress behaviour during training and bigger rises in the stress hormone cortisol afterwards.
It’s worth saying that these studies can’t always untangle which came first – a worried dog may also be more likely to be on the receiving end of harsher handling – but the pattern points in a consistent direction.
It’s not just dogs. A large review pulling together studies across 22 species found that animals living in better conditions generally made more optimistic judgements, although the effects were often small and varied a lot between studies.
And a 2026 systematic review of 32 canine judgement-bias studies adds a sensible note of caution.
Overall, these tests do seem sensitive to some changes in emotional state, and to things like enrichment and training method.
But the authors also flagged real limitations: dogs don’t always score consistently when retested, methods vary a lot between studies, and the results only partly line up with other welfare measures.
So we have a meaningful pattern, but not yet a test that can tell you whether your individual dog is an “optimist” or a “pessimist”.
What about the human end of the lead?
Tracy made a comment in our discussion that I suspect will ring true for a lot of you: she and her husband have noticed that they’re more alert, and more pessimistic, when walking their reactive dog.
There’s a fascinating scientific parallel here.
Dogs gather information from us all the time.
In one study, dogs whose owners sent positive emotional signals approached an unfamiliar object more readily than dogs whose owners sent negative ones.
And a small 2024 study from Bristol found that the smell of a stressed stranger nudged dogs towards slightly more cautious choices in one part of a judgement-bias test.
But let’s be clear: this does not mean your stress makes your dog reactive. These were small studies with modest effects, and your feelings are one source of information among many.
What it does suggest is a very understandable feedback loop.
Your dog gets worried or wound up.
You, quite reasonably, become more watchful.
Your dog picks up a little more information from you.
And over time, you both get very good at predicting trouble.
If you’ve become a hyper-vigilant walker, it’s because you’ve learned from experience. That’s you being the switched-on, responsible person your dog needs.
The good news is that as your dog’s predictions start to change, yours can too – which helps you both.
What might good training actually be changing?
So, back to Sharon’s question:
Does training change behaviour, or does it change feelings?
I don’t think we have to choose. Good behaviour modification may be working on several levels at once:
- Skills. Your dog learns things to do instead of escalating – orienting back to you, moving away, pausing, sniffing, taking a known route, or settling.
- Agency. Your dog learns they have workable options. Having some control over what happens is itself good for welfare, and may reduce frantic responding.
- Prediction. Repeated safe experiences gradually update “what usually happens next”. A trigger that once predicted threat, frustration or chaos may increasingly predict distance, food, support or simply nothing much at all.
- Threshold and recovery. Successful repetitions can change how easily your dog tips over, and how quickly they come back down afterwards.
- Flexibility. Instead of one well-worn response, your dog builds a wider repertoire of things they can do when the world is uncertain.
- Your predictions. You get better at reading early signs and making good choices, so fewer walks begin with both of you expecting disaster.
Notice that “make the dog an optimist” isn’t on that list.
For me, a more useful aim is to help your dog build more flexible, context-appropriate expectations and responses.
Sometimes that means more hope.
Sometimes it means a little less certainty that the moving thing is the best thing ever.
Almost always, it means more choices.
So, Sharon – here’s my answer
Is it right or helpful to see reactive dogs as pessimistic?
Sometimes, for some dogs.
Worried and fearful dogs may well be expecting the worst, and the research supports that.
But as a general explanation for reactivity, it doesn’t hold up – especially for the excited, frustrated and movement-driven Collies so many of us live with.
Does training make them more optimistic, or just teach them to cope?
Potentially both.
Training can certainly teach coping skills without changing how a dog feels.
But some studies suggest that a dog’s underlying expectations can shift too.
Can we really change the way a dog sees the world?
In a careful sense, yes.
Experience can change what a dog expects when they don’t yet know what’s coming.
Temperament may influence the starting point, but it isn’t destiny. I find it helpful to think in probabilities rather than personality labels.
So next time your Collie stands at that field gate, scanning the hedgeline, I’d gently invite you to swap the question.
Not “is my dog a pessimist?” but “what has my dog learned to predict here – and what new answers can I help them discover?”
Because perhaps that’s the real work. Not turning our dogs into optimists, but helping them learn, one safe experience at a time, that there are more possible answers than the one they’ve rehearsed.
Want to explore this with other Collie owners?
This whole post began with one member’s thoughtful question, and that’s exactly the kind of conversation we have inside the Collie Culture Club – real questions from real Collie owners, explored with curiosity, compassion and evidence.
If you’d like to be part of it, join the Collie Culture Club waitlist and you’ll be the first to hear when the doors open.
PS If you’ve ever felt guilty for being the anxious one on walks, please let that go. Your vigilance is a sign of how much you care.
And the research suggests that the conversation between you and your dog really can change direction – not just for them, but for you too.
Further reading
- Mendl M et al. (2010). Dogs showing separation-related behaviour exhibit a “pessimistic” cognitive bias. Current Biology 20(19). doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2010.08.030
- Barnard S et al. (2018). Personality traits affecting judgement bias task performance in dogs (Canis familiaris). Scientific Reports 8:6660.
- Karagiannis CI, Burman OHP, Mills DS (2015). Dogs with separation-related problems show a “less pessimistic” cognitive bias during treatment with fluoxetine and a behaviour modification plan. BMC Veterinary Research 11:80. doi.org/10.1186/s12917-015-0373-1
- Duranton C, Horowitz A (2019). Let me sniff! Nosework induces positive judgment bias in pet dogs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 211:61-66. doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2018.12.009
- Willen RM, Schiml PA, Hennessy MB (2019). Enrichment centered on human interaction moderates fear-induced aggression and increases positive expectancy in fearful shelter dogs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science. doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2019.05.001
- Vieira de Castro AC et al. (2020). Does training method matter? Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare. PLoS ONE 15(12). doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0225023
- Casey RA et al. (2021). Dogs are more pessimistic if their owners use two or more aversive training methods. Scientific Reports 11:19023. doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-97743-0
- Lagisz M et al. (2020). Optimism, pessimism and judgement bias in animals: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 118:3-17. doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2020.07.012
- Merola I, Prato-Previde E, Marshall-Pescini S (2012). Dogs’ social referencing towards owners and strangers. PLoS ONE 7(10). doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0047653
- Parr-Cortes Z et al. (2024). The odour of an unfamiliar stressed or relaxed person affects dogs’ responses to a cognitive bias test. Scientific Reports 14:15843. doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-66147-1
- Gazzano V et al. (2026). Assessing affective states in domestic dogs through judgment bias tasks: a systematic review of methods, influencing factors, and welfare applications. Frontiers in Veterinary Science. doi.org/10.3389/fvets.2026.1926433